Ever wondered if biting gold proves it’s real or if mixing metals is a fashion faux pas? Jewelry has long been surrounded by stories, traditions and half-truths that shape how we buy and wear it. From so-called ‘rules’ about which metals suit your skin tone to old wives’ tales about cleaning gemstones, these jewelry myths can often lead to confusion – or even damage your favorite pieces.
In this guide, we’re uncovering the truth behind the most common jewelry myths. Whether you’re investing in gold, shopping for an engagement ring or simply looking to care for your jewelry properly, we’ll help you separate fact from fiction.
Myth 1: Diamonds are the most expensive gemstones
Diamonds have long been marketed as the ultimate symbol of luxury, but their reputation doesn’t always reflect reality. While they’re prized for their brilliance and meaningful significance, they aren’t necessarily the rarest or most valuable gemstones. Stones like alexandrite, red beryl and painite are far less common and generally more expensive. Typically, gemstone value depends on individuality, quality and demand. So, while diamonds are one of the most popular stones, this gemstone myth reminds us that rarity is what determines true worth.
Myth 2: Diamond is the best stone for an engagement ring
One of the most enduring diamond myths is that a diamond is the only ‘proper’ choice for an engagement ring. In reality, the best gemstone is one that fits your lifestyle, budget and taste. Sapphires, moissanite and emeralds are all stunning, durable alternatives that offer unique colors and symbolism. While diamonds remain the most traditional option, this engagement ring myth overlooks individuality and personal preference. Ultimately, you should pick a stone that feels meaningful to you and your partner. Interested in a gemstone engagement ring? Check out our top picks for 2025.
Myth 3: All gold is the same
When it comes to gold myths, one of the biggest misconceptions is that all gold jewelry is created equal. In reality, gold differs in purity, durability and value. Pure 24-carat gold is soft and prone to scratches and bending, while lower-carat gold, such as 14-carat or 18-carat, is alloyed with metals like silver or copper for added strength, making it ideal for everyday wear. In our gold guide, you can learn more about the purity of each carat and what alloys are used to create a specific type of gold.
Another common myth? That ‘biting gold’ can prove authenticity by seeing if teeth marks are left. This outdated trick can actually damage both your jewelry and your teeth. It’s also crucial to distinguish between solid gold, gold-plated and gold-filled jewelry. Understanding these distinctions helps ensure you’re making informed purchases and getting fair value for your jewelry.
Myth 4: You can’t wear gold & silver together
Forget the old metal mixing myths – today, combining gold and silver is a trend that’s widely embraced. Modern style champions versatility and mixing metals can add depth and character to your look. To achieve balance, try distributing metals evenly and use transitional pieces that will help to blend the different tones. For instance, pair a gold pendant with a silver chain or stack mixed-metal rings.
Myth 5: Your skin tone can only wear one metal color
This metal myth suggests that warm skin tones can only wear gold and cool tones should stick to silver, but this isn’t always the case. While certain metals may complement undertones differently, personal preference should always win. If you love rose gold, platinum or a mix of metals, wear what speaks to your style.
Myth 6: Jewelry can be cleaned with toothpaste
One of the most persistent jewelry cleaning myths is that toothpaste is a safe, effective cleaner. In reality, it’s abrasive and can scratch metals and dull gemstones. Instead, opt for mild soap, warm water and a soft cloth or take your jewelry for a professional clean. Understanding proper care techniques ensures your pieces last beautifully for years to come. For more information on how to care for your jewelry and keep it looking its best, head to our jewelry care guide.
Myth 7: Wearing silver causes skin discoloration
Another common misconception is that silver jewelry can discolor the skin. While some people may notice a faint greenish tint after wearing silver, it’s not a sign of poor quality. Silver alloys can react with natural elements on your skin – such as sweat, lotions or even humidity – resulting in temporary tarnish. It’s also worth noting that sterling silver (92.5% pure silver) is generally more resistant, while plated silver may show wear more quickly. To help prevent discoloration, keep your jewelry clean and dry.
Myth 8: Bigger diamonds are better
It’s not necessarily the bigger the better when it comes to diamonds. A large stone with poor cut or clarity may sparkle less than a smaller, well-cut gem with exceptional brilliance. The true measure of a diamond’s beauty lies in the 4Cs: cut, color, clarity and carat weight. So, this diamond myth actually overlooks what truly matters: quality and craftsmanship. Our advice? Always go for sparkle over size.
Quick tips to avoid falling for jewelry myths
To make confident choices when investing in jewelry, start by questioning common myths and turning to trusted, certified jewelers or reputable sources for guidance. Instead of relying on viral cleaning hacks or old-fashioned rules, take time to learn about materials, gemstones and proper care techniques, so you can make informed decisions and assured purchases.
Truth over tradition & tales
From gold myths to gemstone legends, we’ve debunked some of the most common jewelry misconceptions that can mislead buyers. With the right knowledge, you can choose, wear and care for your pieces with confidence. Whether it’s understanding that bigger diamonds aren’t always better, silver won’t permanently discolor your skin or toothpaste isn’t an effective cleaner, these jewelry insights should empower you to make informed choices. By questioning old tales and relying on trusted sources, you can enjoy your jewelry with certainty.
Explore our diamond jewelry collections with confidence, knowing the facts.
blog_related_products_section
link copied
Request a virtual appointment
Ever wondered if biting gold proves it’s real or if mixing metals is a fashion faux pas? Jewelry has long been surrounded by stories, traditions and half-truths that shape how we buy and wear it. From so-called ‘rules’ about which metals suit your skin tone to old wives’ tales about cleaning gemstones, these jewelry myths can often lead to confusion – or even damage your favorite pieces.
In this guide, we’re uncovering the truth behind the most common jewelry myths. Whether you’re investing in gold, shopping for an engagement ring or simply looking to care for your jewelry properly, we’ll help you separate fact from fiction.
Myth 1: Diamonds are the most expensive gemstones
Diamonds have long been marketed as the ultimate symbol of luxury, but their reputation doesn’t always reflect reality. While they’re prized for their brilliance and meaningful significance, they aren’t necessarily the rarest or most valuable gemstones. Stones like alexandrite, red beryl and painite are far less common and generally more expensive. Typically, gemstone value depends on individuality, quality and demand. So, while diamonds are one of the most popular stones, this gemstone myth reminds us that rarity is what determines true worth.
Myth 2: Diamond is the best stone for an engagement ring
One of the most enduring diamond myths is that a diamond is the only ‘proper’ choice for an engagement ring. In reality, the best gemstone is one that fits your lifestyle, budget and taste. Sapphires, moissanite and emeralds are all stunning, durable alternatives that offer unique colors and symbolism. While diamonds remain the most traditional option, this engagement ring myth overlooks individuality and personal preference. Ultimately, you should pick a stone that feels meaningful to you and your partner. Interested in a gemstone engagement ring? Check out our top picks for 2025.
Myth 3: All gold is the same
When it comes to gold myths, one of the biggest misconceptions is that all gold jewelry is created equal. In reality, gold differs in purity, durability and value. Pure 24-carat gold is soft and prone to scratches and bending, while lower-carat gold, such as 14-carat or 18-carat, is alloyed with metals like silver or copper for added strength, making it ideal for everyday wear. In our gold guide, you can learn more about the purity of each carat and what alloys are used to create a specific type of gold.
Another common myth? That ‘biting gold’ can prove authenticity by seeing if teeth marks are left. This outdated trick can actually damage both your jewelry and your teeth. It’s also crucial to distinguish between solid gold, gold-plated and gold-filled jewelry. Understanding these distinctions helps ensure you’re making informed purchases and getting fair value for your jewelry.
Myth 4: You can’t wear gold & silver together
Forget the old metal mixing myths – today, combining gold and silver is a trend that’s widely embraced. Modern style champions versatility and mixing metals can add depth and character to your look. To achieve balance, try distributing metals evenly and use transitional pieces that will help to blend the different tones. For instance, pair a gold pendant with a silver chain or stack mixed-metal rings.
Myth 5: Your skin tone can only wear one metal color
This metal myth suggests that warm skin tones can only wear gold and cool tones should stick to silver, but this isn’t always the case. While certain metals may complement undertones differently, personal preference should always win. If you love rose gold, platinum or a mix of metals, wear what speaks to your style.
Myth 6: Jewelry can be cleaned with toothpaste
One of the most persistent jewelry cleaning myths is that toothpaste is a safe, effective cleaner. In reality, it’s abrasive and can scratch metals and dull gemstones. Instead, opt for mild soap, warm water and a soft cloth or take your jewelry for a professional clean. Understanding proper care techniques ensures your pieces last beautifully for years to come. For more information on how to care for your jewelry and keep it looking its best, head to our jewelry care guide.
Myth 7: Wearing silver causes skin discoloration
Another common misconception is that silver jewelry can discolor the skin. While some people may notice a faint greenish tint after wearing silver, it’s not a sign of poor quality. Silver alloys can react with natural elements on your skin – such as sweat, lotions or even humidity – resulting in temporary tarnish. It’s also worth noting that sterling silver (92.5% pure silver) is generally more resistant, while plated silver may show wear more quickly. To help prevent discoloration, keep your jewelry clean and dry.
Myth 8: Bigger diamonds are better
It’s not necessarily the bigger the better when it comes to diamonds. A large stone with poor cut or clarity may sparkle less than a smaller, well-cut gem with exceptional brilliance. The true measure of a diamond’s beauty lies in the 4Cs: cut, color, clarity and carat weight. So, this diamond myth actually overlooks what truly matters: quality and craftsmanship. Our advice? Always go for sparkle over size.
Quick tips to avoid falling for jewelry myths
To make confident choices when investing in jewelry, start by questioning common myths and turning to trusted, certified jewelers or reputable sources for guidance. Instead of relying on viral cleaning hacks or old-fashioned rules, take time to learn about materials, gemstones and proper care techniques, so you can make informed decisions and assured purchases.
Truth over tradition & tales
From gold myths to gemstone legends, we’ve debunked some of the most common jewelry misconceptions that can mislead buyers. With the right knowledge, you can choose, wear and care for your pieces with confidence. Whether it’s understanding that bigger diamonds aren’t always better, silver won’t permanently discolor your skin or toothpaste isn’t an effective cleaner, these jewelry insights should empower you to make informed choices. By questioning old tales and relying on trusted sources, you can enjoy your jewelry with certainty.
blog_related_products_sectionExplore our diamond jewelry collections with confidence, knowing the facts.